I agree with Pete massively!
It's all about personal opinion and experience.... I had a horrendous issue on my first ever stay at ATH, contracted food poisoning at some point on resort and ruined my visit.
I was then invited back for a 2 day stay at Scarefest, stayed in Splash and had a epic stay!
Say for 2 nights, 1 night in each hotel and I'll get you a 50% off hotel bookings for your visit :-)
I would have to agree they are different things I stayed for the first time and went to splash landings it was great for the kids but as an adult found it a bit too kiddy children's entertainer shouting down a microphone and all sorts is that wrong? No it's perfect for the kids I went over to ATH both evening for a drink in the Garden which was amazing
the debate it like askingmwhich is better Charlie and the chocholate factory or oblivion?
they are different things you can't compare them you just have to pick what your looking for
I hope to stay in ATH however if only SL is available then so what I'm happy